Spot on Shaun!!! This is exactly what I’ve been banging on about over the past six years – very nice validation from a top-notch theorist. The fruits of my labour will be available in its full form next year as a book entitled Stigmergic Cognition.
May 14, 2013
Short URL Andy Clark, Cognitive science, complexity, consciousness, Critical theory, David Chalmers, enactivism, Epistemology, Extended Mind, Externalism, Institutions, Parity Principle, philosophical psychology, Philosophy of mind, Shaun Gallagher, Social affordances, Social Sciences, Spontaneous order extended mind
This from Froese, Gershenson, and Rosenblueth.
The extended mind hypothesis has stimulated much interest in cognitive science. However, its core claim, i.e. that the process of cognition can extend beyond the brain via the body and into the environment, has been heavily criticized. A prominent critique of this claim holds that when some part of the world is coupled to a cognitive system this does not necessarily entail that the part is also constitutive of that cognitive system. This critique is known as the “coupling-constitution fallacy”. In this paper we respond to this reductionist challenge by using an evolutionary robotics approach to create a minimal model of two acoustically coupled agents. We demonstrate how the interaction process as a whole has properties that cannot be reduced to the contributions of the isolated agents. We also show that the neural dynamics of the coupled agents has formal properties that are inherently impossible for those neural networks in isolation. By keeping the complexity of the model to an absolute minimum, we are able to illustrate how the coupling-constitution fallacy is in fact based on an inadequate understanding of the constitutive role of nonlinear interactions in dynamical systems theory.
May 10, 2013
Short URL Andy Clark, Artificial intelligence, Cognition, Cognitive science, complexity, Dynamical system, Embodied cognition, evolutionary robotics, Extended Mind, Externalism, Fred Adams, Ken Aizawa, Neural Networks, Philosophy of mind, Stigmergy extended mind, externalism
Andy Clark lecture.
February 20, 2013
Short URL Andy Clark, Artificial intelligence, Cognition, Cognitive neuroscience, Cognitive science, complexity, consciousness, cyborgs, Embodied cognition, Extended Mind, Externalism, philosophical psychology, Philosophy of mind, Stigmergy Andy Clark
This book features a chapter by Andy Clark entitled: How to Qualify for a Cognitive Upgrade: Executive Control, Glass Ceilings, and the Limits of Simian Success. Here is the intro to the chapter:
10.1 Introduction
It is sometimes suggested that words and language form a kind of ‘cognitive niche’ (Clark, 1998, 2005, 2006, 2008; Chapter 4): an animal-built structure that productively transforms our cognitive capacities. But even if language cognitively empowers us in many deep and unobvious ways, it would be quite wrong to assume that such empowerment occurs in either a neural or an evolutionary vacuum. In evolutionary terms, we need to recognise the various precursors of our own prodigious skills at species-level selfscaffolding. In neural terms, we need to uncover the specific innovations that allow certain kinds of agents to benefit (humans massively, simians somewhat, hamsters not at all) from the empowering effects of exposure to a public linguistic edifice. What we need to understand is thus a delicate balancing act between extra-neural and neural innovation, such that the public material structures of language are enabled (in some beings and not in others) to play significant cognitive roles. In the present chapter, I first lay out a few of the ways in which language may indeed act as a potent form of cognitive scaffolding. I then briefly rehearse the results of a series of elegant comparative and developmental studies (summarised in McGonigle and Chalmers [2006]) that suggest a surprising amount of evolutionary continuity between human and simian (squirrel monkey) subjects in respect of some of the key ‘building block’ skills that enable this potent ‘mind-tool’ (Dennett, 2000) to emerge. I end by asking, ‘What then limits simian success?’
November 17, 2012
Short URL Andy Clark, Artificial intelligence, Cognition, Cognitive neuroscience, Cognitive science, complexity, consciousness, Extended Mind, Externalism, Social Sciences Andy Clark
October 9, 2012
Short URL Andy Clark, Cognition, Cognitive science, David Chalmers, Extended Mind, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel, Hegel, metaphysics, Philosophy of mind extended mind, externalism
Check out this essay forthcoming from the power team of Clark, Kilverstein and Farina.
Sensory substitution devices are a type of sensory prosthesis that (typically) convert visual stimuli transduced by a camera into tactile or auditory stimulation. They are designed to be used by people with impaired vision so that they can recover some of the functions normally subserved by vision. In this chapter we will consider what philosophers might learn about the nature of the senses from the neuroscience of sensory substitution. We will show how sensory substitution devices work by exploiting the cross-modal plasticity of sensory cortex: the ability of sensory cortex to pick up some types of information about the external environment irrespective of the nature of the sensory inputs it is processing. We explore the implications of cross-modal plasticity for theories of the senses that attempt to make distinctions between the senses on the basis of neurobiology.
September 20, 2012
Short URL Andy Clark, Cognitive science, julian kilverstein, mirko farina, neuroscience, Philosophy of mind, Sensory cortex, Sensory substitution distributed cognition, distributed knowledge, embodied cognition, embodiment, enactivism, extended cognitive systems, extended mind, externalism
Well, this article was inevitable - first mentioned here). Francis Heylighen has been talking about this for a few years now as has myself in discussing Hayek, distributed cognition and co-evolved mind and sociality not to mention my ongoing interest in stigmergy which I argue is a species of EM.
Abstract: This article explores the notion of the Web-extended mind, which is the idea that the technological and informational elements of the Web can sometimes serve as part of the mechanistic substrate that realizes human mental states and processes. It is argued that while current forms of the Web may not be particularly suited to the realization of Web-extended minds, new forms of user interaction technology as well as new approaches to information representation do provide promising new opportunities for Web-based forms of cognitive extension. In addition, it is suggested that extended cognitive systems often rely on the emergence of social practices and conventions that shape how a technology is used. Web-extended minds may thus depend on forms of socio-technical co-evolution in which social forces and factors play just as important a role as do the processes of technology design and development.
Keywords: cognition, cognitive extension, cognitive technology, extended mind, Internet, linked data, Web science, World Wide Web.
July 17, 2012
Short URL Andy Clark, Cognition, Cognitive science, complexity, Extended Mind, Externalism, Francis Heylighen, Friedrich Hayek, Mind, Stigmergy complexity, distributed cognition, distributed knowledge, global brain, network theory, networks, neural networks, social connectionism, social epistemology, sociocognition, spontaneous orders, stigmergic, stigmergic cognition, stigmergy
July 3, 2012
Short URL Andy Clark, Clark, Cognition, Embodied cognition, Extended Mind, Social Sciences Andy Clark, david chalmers, Embedded, embodied cognition, embodiment, extended cognitive systems, extended mind, externalism, situated cognition
This from the European Journal of Philosophy. Unfortunately, the citation -
Fisher, J. (2009), ‘Critical Notice of The Bounds of Cognition’, Journal of Mind and Brain, 29: 345–57.
should be:
Fisher, J. (2008). ‘Critical Notice for The Bounds of Cognition’, Journal of Mind and Behavior, 29: 345-357.
June 26, 2012
Short URL Andy Clark, Cognition, Cognitive neuroscience, Cognitive science, consciousness, Embodied cognition, Extended Mind, philosophical psychology, Philosophy of mind Adams & Aizawa, extended mind, externalism, John Haugeland
Marge and my intro now available as an uncorrected proof. Stay tuned for the rest of the papers comprising this special issue.
According to Andy Clark “[M]uch of what goes on in the complex world of humans, may thus, somewhat surprisingly, be understood in terms of so-called stigmergic algorithms” (Clark, 1996, p. 279; 1997, p. 186). Pierre-Paul Grassé, the brilliant mind who first conceptualized the notion probably wouldn’t disagree (Grassé, 1959). Grassé was as much a zoologist as he was an entomologist. Under his editorship the monumental (17-volume) Traité de Zoologie, Anatomie, Systématique, Biologie was guided.
June 24, 2012
Short URL Andy Clark, Ant, Cognitive science, complexity, Grassé, Philosophy of mind, Pierre-Paul Grassé, social epistemology, Social Sciences, Spontaneous order, Stigmergy, Traité de Zoologie adam smith, complexity, distributed cognition, distributed knowledge, Don Lavoie, extended cognitive systems, extended mind, externalism, hayek, Herbert Simon, Margery Doyle, stigmergic, stigmergic cognition, stigmergy